Mazzio’s Pizza

Reviews

• Ayala M.

  star star star star_border star_border 10 June 2026

  While traveling to Marshall to see my son play college football we decided to order pizza from this local joint. When we first saw Mazzios Pizza we all got super excited. In high school this pizza spot was #1 in Fort Worth. We would go eat here at least 2-3 times a week but of course I was young, metabolism was at an all time high so the fear of weight gain was non existent. Okay enough rambling the service was great and the pizza was really good. Nothing like I remembered  but after traveling for 10 hours we really didn't care. If you're in this cute town stop here and grab a bottle a wine and enjoy some pizza.

• Matt A.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 7 June 2026

  My family has eaten here 3 times. We usually meet my in laws here due to it being halfway between STL and where they live. The first 2 times we ate we were pleased with the amount of food available on the buffet and the flavor was decent for buffet food.
  
  The 3rd time was a HUGE disappointment. We were seated around 1130am on a Sunday. The buffet was not available so we ordered some pizzas and a couple of side. The drinks came pretty quickly but the food took an hour and 15 minutes. My kids were irate and going crazy. We asked the waiter several times the status of our food and he insisted he was going to check but would never come back. I spoke with the waiter after we were done and explained my extreme displeasure with the service. We probably will come back sometime but may take a break for a bit.

• Justin A.

  star star star star star_border 1 June 2026

  My boyfriend and I came here to partake in the lunch buffet, and I was pretty happy with the experience. The price was a bit higher than another pizza buffet that shall remain nameless, but the quality of the food is much much higher. I've had better pizza, but for a much higher price. The cookie pizza was one of the best cookie-ish foods I've had in a bit (though the brownies were super-meh). The service was really good, and our server was very helpful in facilitating our buffet request when we had one. The only real complaint I had is that the edge of the crust was a bit hard and just kinda flaky-weird. I'd recommend Mazzios' buffet to anyone in the mood for pizza.

• Patricia F.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 14 May 2026

  One of the worst restaurants that I have ever been to. As my boyfriend and I walked in, not only were we the only the people there, but no one greeted us. Two bored servers said at us and finally after a long staring contest, the male server told us to sit anywhere. We sat and ordered shortly after. I ordered a Dr. Pepper, which came out in a sticky glass, and was extremely flat, and my boyfriend ordered a water, which was never refilled during our hour stay. Soon after we ordered an appetizer, the cheese dippers, which was, hands down, the best thing that we ate there. For my dinner I ordered the four-cheese calzone, with no meat and my boyfriend ordered a sandwhich with fries. After about a half hour wait, our food finally came out, even with being the only people there. My calzone was full of meat and my boyfriends fries had another fifteen minute wait added to them. When we complained to our server, john, who we rarely saw, he was rude and made point to apologize. However, being the fine server that john was, he did hand us our check while we were still eating. To top the wonderful evening off, when trying to pay, my boyfriend tried to pay with a fifty when they attempted to give him thirty dollars in ones. By far this is one of the worst restaurants both food and service wise. I am not one for writing reviews but I would not recommend this to my worst enemy.